[G.Polya]
Routine
Problem May be called the problem to solve the equation
x^2-3x+2=0 if the solution of the general
quadratic equation was explained and illustrated
before so that the student has nothing to do but to
substitute the numbers -3 and 2 for certain letters which
appear in the general solution. even if the quadratic
equation was not solved generally in letters but half
a dozen similar quadratic equations with numerical
coefficients were solved just before, the problem should
be called a "routine problem." In general, a problem is
a "routine problem" if it can be solved either by
substituting special data into a formerly solved general problem
or by following step by step, without any trace of
originality, some well worn conspicuous example. Setting
a routine problem, the teacher thrusts under the nose of
the student an immediately and decisive answer to the
question Do you know a related problem? Thus the
student needs nothing but a little care and patience in
following a cut and dried precept, and he has no opportunity
to use his judgement or his inventive faculties.
Routine problems, even many routine problems, may
be necessary in teaching mathematics but to make the
students do no other kind is inexcusable. Teaching the
mechanical performance of routine mathematical
operations and nothing else is well under the level of the
cookbook because kitchen recipes do leave something to
the imagination and judgement of the cook but mathematical
recipes do not.